Most sellers pick a distributor the same way they pick a restaurant: a quick look at the menu and a hunch. That works until the first order arrives late, the invoice is missing a detail, or the margin disappears after Amazon’s fees. A better approach is to score every candidate on the same criteria, so the decision comes from numbers instead of a feeling.
This guide gives you a simple, weighted scorecard for comparing wholesale distributors for Amazon FBA. If you are still learning what distributors do and which types exist, start with our main guide on how to find, vet and choose wholesale distributors for Amazon FBA, then come back here to compare your shortlist.
Quick Answer: What Should You Compare?
Rate each distributor from 1 to 5 on six things: authenticity and invoices, net margin after fees, catalog fit, stock reliability, prep and shipping, and support. Weight the scores by importance, add them up, and treat any failure on authenticity as an automatic “no”, whatever the total says.
The Six-Point Distributor Scorecard
| Criteria | Weight | What a strong answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Authenticity and invoices | 25 | Buys from brands or authorized channels and issues clear invoices with business details, products and quantities |
| Net margin after fees | 20 | Most products still earn a healthy profit after Amazon fees, prep and shipping |
| Catalog fit and approvals | 15 | Carries brands and categories you are allowed to sell and actually want to sell |
| Stock reliability and reorders | 15 | Keeps repeat sellers in stock and tells you early when something runs out |
| Prep and shipping | 15 | Ships products in original packaging, packs fragile items carefully and gives realistic delivery times |
| Support and communication | 10 | A real person replies quickly and clearly |
The weights add up to 100. Authenticity carries the most weight because everything else depends on it: a cheap product you cannot prove is genuine is a liability, not a bargain.
1. Authenticity and Invoices
Ask where the products come from and request a sample invoice before you apply. You want to see a business name and address, product descriptions and quantities. Keep every invoice you receive, because Amazon can ask you to prove your inventory is genuine. Our checklist on choosing a reliable wholesale supplier for Amazon FBA explains the paperwork to look for.
2. Net Margin After Fees
A low wholesale price means nothing until you subtract Amazon’s costs. Use this formula on a sample of products from each distributor, not just the best-looking ones:
Net profit per unit = Buy Box price − wholesale cost − referral fee − FBA fee − prep and inbound shipping − advertising
Here is a purely illustrative example. A product sells for $24.00 and costs $12.50 wholesale. The referral fee is $3.60, the FBA fee is $4.10 and prep plus inbound shipping is $0.60. That leaves $3.20 per unit, a 13.3% margin on the selling price and a 25.6% return on your cost. These figures are examples, so check Amazon’s current fee schedule and FBA revenue calculator for your own products. With Amazon’s 2027 FBA fee changes arriving in January, it is worth rerunning the numbers, as covered in our guide to Amazon FBA wholesale in 2027. Our profitability checklist walks through the same check for individual products.
3. Catalog Fit and Approvals
A huge catalog is no use if most of it is gated or restricted for your account. Look at the brands a distributor carries and the categories it covers, such as Health & Household, Beauty & Personal Care, Grocery & Gourmet Food, Baby Care and Pet Supplies. Then check which of those categories you can sell today.
4. Stock Reliability and Reorders
Wholesale works because you can reorder products that sell. Ask how often inventory is updated and what happens when an item is out of stock. A distributor that cannot restock your bestsellers will cost you sales and ranking.
5. Prep and Shipping
Find out how products are packed, whether they arrive in original retail packaging and how long delivery usually takes. Read the distributor’s shipping policy and compare it with what you need. Our guide on case packs versus individual units explains how wholesale inventory is usually shipped.
6. Support and Communication
Send a real question through the distributor’s contact page and note how quickly and how clearly it is answered. How a distributor behaves before you are a customer is the best preview of how it behaves when something goes wrong.
How to Calculate the Score
Give each criterion a score from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). Multiply each score by its weight, add the results and divide by 5 to get a total out of 100. Below is a hypothetical comparison of three distributors, using the weights above.
| Criteria (weight) | Distributor A | Distributor B | Distributor C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Authenticity and invoices (25) | 5 | 3 | 2 |
| Net margin after fees (20) | 3 | 5 | 4 |
| Catalog fit (15) | 4 | 3 | 3 |
| Stock reliability (15) | 4 | 2 | 3 |
| Prep and shipping (15) | 4 | 3 | 2 |
| Support (10) | 5 | 3 | 2 |
| Total out of 100 | 83 | 65 | 54 |
Distributor B has the best margins, but weak stock and average authenticity pull it down. Distributor A wins because it is solid everywhere that matters over the long run. That is a typical pattern: the cheapest option is rarely the best one once reliability is counted.
Rules That Override the Score
- Score of 1 on authenticity or invoices: reject the distributor, whatever its total.
- No verifiable business address, phone number or written policies: reject.
- Prices far below the market with no clear reason: investigate before going further.
- Pressure to pay quickly or by unusual methods: walk away.
Test Before You Commit
A scorecard narrows the field, but a small test order settles it. Order a modest quantity of a few products, then check whether the items match the invoice, arrive in good condition and ship on time. Our article on how much wholesale inventory a new Amazon seller should buy can help you size that first order. After the test, update your scores with what really happened and scale only with the distributors that held up. Over time, consistency pays off, as explained in our post on building a long-term relationship with a wholesale distributor.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many wholesale distributors should I compare?
Three to five is enough. Fewer gives you little to compare, and more usually means you are spending time on distributors that would not have passed the authenticity check anyway.
Is the cheapest distributor the best choice for Amazon FBA?
Not necessarily. A low price helps only if the products are genuine, in stock and still profitable after Amazon’s fees. Reliability and paperwork often matter more than a few cents per unit.
Can I change the weights in the scorecard?
Yes. If you sell mostly low-priced items, you might raise the weight on margin. If you sell restricted categories, raise catalog fit. Just keep authenticity near the top.
How do I apply for a wholesale account with Nations Distributor?
Submit the wholesale application. You can also read the How It Works page and the FAQs to see how ordering works before you apply.
Final Thoughts
Choosing among wholesale distributors for Amazon FBA gets much easier when every option is judged by the same yardstick. Score them, apply the deal-breaker rules, run a small test order and let the results decide. Ready to see how Nations Distributor scores for your business? Apply for a wholesale account or contact our team with your product needs.